News Reviews How-To's Downloads Shop & Compare Forums Business Center 
NEW Android App Guide iPhone App Guide All PCWorld Blogs » All PCWorld Videos » 
Cameras 
Camcorders 
Cell Phones 
Components 
Desktops 
HDTV 
Home Theater 
GPS 
Laptops 
Monitors 
MP3 Players 
Networking &Wireless
Printers 
Storage Software Antivirus & Security Browsers & Add-ons Operating Systems Multimedia Utilities Games Popular Topics Consumer Advice Gadgets Gaming Macs & iPods Mobile Security Tech Industry Tech Events Upgrading Windows 7 Featured BrandsShop Acer ProductsCisco Small BusinessDiscover HP Printing SolutionsSave 50% Per Color PrintWorld's First Web-Connected Home PrinterShop Lenovo Laptops 
MagazineSubscribe & Get a Bonus CD Customer Service
Discover news, guides, and products for your business
Software & ServicesOffice HardwareSecurityServers & StorageCell Phones & MobileOperating SystemsNetworking & VOIPVirtualizationfunction submitNewsletterSubscriptionHeaderModule(){var postData=$("#newsletterModuleForm").serialize();var requestOptions={url: '/newsletters/pcw_module_processor',data: postData,success: function(data,textStatus){$("#newsletterSubscribeHeader").fadeOut("slow",function(){$(this).html(data).fadeIn("slow");})}};$.ajax(requestOptions);}
Net WorkPractical IT insight from Tony Bradley » More Net Work » RSS » All Blogs Security October 08, 2010 12:53 PMFacebook Groups Prank Shows Problem with Default Opt-In
More…
Facebook
Twitter
Digg
Print By Tony Bradley, PCWorldFacebook held a major press event this week to introduce some significant changes to the site, including Facebook Groups. While the intent of Facebook Groups is to enhance privacy and provide users with more control over how information is shared, the implementation of the concept leaves a little to be desired.
People who read this also read:
Facebook's New Groups: 5 Things You Need To Know
New Facebook Groups: 5 Key FactsFacebook’s Promising, Infuriating New Groups Feature
Facebook Ads: Success Secrets From a Facebook Insider
Has Facebook Finally Figured Out Privacy?
New Facebook Features: Prepare for More CliquesChet Wisniewski, a senior security advisor with Sophos, describes the problem in a blog post. "Facebook's newly announced groups feature may not be the boon for privacy some have predicted. Although only a small percentage of Facebook's users are upgraded to the new features it would appear people are exploring the possibilities in a rather aggressive way."
Wisniewski goes on to explain, "The problem of course is that you can create a group with any name you want, and add any friends you want without any confirmation that they wish to be a member of said group. It would seem obvious that this is a terrible idea because when you are added to a group it will post a status update saying you joined it... And it didn't take long before someone used it on Zuck."
What Wisniewski is referring to is that someone set up a Facebook Group for NAMBLA--the pro-pedophile North American Man Boy Love Association--and added TechCrunch's Michael Arrington to it. Arrington, appreciating the irony of the prank, then paid it forward by adding Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. If Zuckerberg and the Facebook team didn't understand the issue before, this prank should be a poignant example of the problem with default opt-in and no approval or confirmation process.
The Facebook Help Center answers the question "Can I Prevent People From Adding Me to a New Group?" with the following: "The functionality of approving a group membership is not available. Similar to being tagged in a photo, you can only be added to a group by one of your friends. When a friend adds you to a group, a story in the group (and in News Feed for Open or Closed groups) will indicate that your friend has added you to a group."
However, once you have been added to a group, you can remove yourself from that group, and once you remove yourself from a group you can't be added to that same group again by any of your Facebook friends.
Wisniewski laments, "There doesn't seem to be a way to opt-out of this feature, although you are notified if you are logged into Facebook. As usual it would appear the ability to connect trumps your ability to decide what should be done with your identity when it comes to Facebook."
And, as usual Facebook's good intentions are thwarted by default opt-in. The underlying concept of Facebook Groups is solid, and I think once the dust settles on this initial launch that it will be successful in meeting the objective Facebook designed it for. But, Facebook should always set up features with assumed privacy and put the ball in the user's court to consciously opt-in to share information.
Was this article useful? Yes 0 No 0#resourceLinks li {display: none;}Sponsored Resource:Find your perfect All-in-One printing solution from HP.Read more like this: Facebook, social networks, online privacyYou can follow Tony on hisFacebook page, or contact him by email attony_bradley@pcworld.com. He also tweets as @Tony_BradleyPCW.
Add YoursComments Readers reply with their ideas and expertise.Subscribe to this discussion via email or RSSWhat do you think? Connect with Facebookwindow.onload = function(){ if (displayFBConnect()){$(".fb-login").show();$(".fb-connect-txt").show();}};function displayFBConnect() { var display = (Logon.isValid && FB.Connect.get_loggedInUser())?false:true; return display;} Posting comment ... Perfect Print Solutions
Find just the right All-in-One Printer for you from HP.Visit the Print Solutions Center.Video Cameras Deliver More Than SecurityFive Keys to a Successful Meeting with your Channel PartnerGet Ready for the Next-Generation InternetNeed a switch? Here's our Top 10 list of FeaturesPartner or Go IT Alone?Join the conversation >>$("#ciscoOOSBlog").click(function(){ window.open("http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;229173421;13346828;f?http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;228869637;52030029;l;");return false;});Business News Daily
Get the latest technology news that's important to you and your business, fresh seven days a week.
function submitNewsletterSubscription(){var postData=$("#newsletterModuleForm").serialize();var requestOptions={url: '/newsletters/pcw_module_processor',data: postData,success: function(data,textStatus){$("#smbRightSubscribe").fadeOut("slow",function(){$(this).html(data).fadeIn("slow");})}};$.ajax(requestOptions)}Internet downloads Download Accelerator Plus Accelerate and more effectively manage your downloads. Microsoft Office 2007 (Free 60-Day Trial)This redesigned productivity suite is powerful and full featured, once you get used to the changes. PageNest Free EditionArchive Web sites to your hard drive for offline browsing--for free. IndustryPlayer - Starter Pack (10 Levels)IndustryPlayer is the most realistic online Business Simulation Game. IndustryPlayer uniquely combines suspense and entertainment with a learning experience. It's the ultimate choice in real-time strategy and tycoon simulation games. Download the free Trial and you can start now! Enjoy IndustryPlayer, the most successful multiplayer online Business Game. IndustryPlayer Starter Pack (10 Levels)Cutting edge entertainment for virtual entrepreneurs! Corporate raiders and hostile takeovers make the cut in this next generation business simulation. IndustryPlayer is an intelligent business sim, targeting the casual and serious gamer. The goal is to build the most successful corporate Holding of 5 companies, manufacturing and selling products to extract maximum profits and finish with the highest accumulated wealth.395 more results...Latest in Business Center Blogs
Net Work - October 10, 2010 7:30 AMWhy Windows Is Good for BusinessAssertions by a Linux-loving PCWorld peer that Windows is bad for business could not be allowed to run uncontested.
BizFeed - October 08, 2010 4:30 PMTrojan Forces Firefox to Save Your PasswordsPhishing malware in the popular Mozilla Firefox browser deactivates browser code that asks if you want passwords to be remembered.
BizFeed - October 08, 2010 4:13 PMWhat You'll Pay For In-Flight Wi-Fi Wireless Internet access can make a long plane trip fly by. Here's what connecting to the Internet on domestic flights will cost you.
Net Work - October 08, 2010 12:53 PMFacebook Groups Prank Shows Problem with Default Opt-InI assume Mark Zuckerberg isn't really a member of NAMBLA, but the prank of adding him without his consent is a poignant example of what's wrong with Facebook Groups.
Net Work - October 08, 2010 10:13 AMFive Reasons to Switch to Windows Phone 7Windows Phone 7 is coming (finally), and these compelling features make it worth considering a switch from rivals like the iPhone or Android handsets.
Linux Line - October 08, 2010 9:58 AM12 Reasons to Try Ubuntu 10.10 NowHave you been wanting to give Ubuntu a test drive? With the debut of user-friendly Maverick Meerkat this weekend, there’s no better time.
All Blogs » Top Small Business Ready Products
Lenovo ThinkPad W701ds 218 people want this 
HP EliteBook 8440w 211 people want this 
Lenovo ThinkPad X100e 134 people want this 
HP ProBook 5310m 172 people want this 
Lenovo ThinkPad SL510 (2847-22U) 130 people want this See all Featured Webcasts 
Top 10 Concerns of Buying a VoIP Business Phone System Type: whitepaper
Company: CompareBusinessProducts.com
Categories: VOIP
Buying a Phone System? Compare the 94 Business Phone Systems in One Chart Type: whitepaper
Company: CompareBusinessProducts.com
Categories: VOIP
More webcasts » Free Whitepapers
Software and Services Whitepapers from PCWorldMore whitepapers » Whitepaper AlertsGet updates on white papers, case studies, and spotlights on tech products and solutions for your business.
function submitNewsletterSubscriptionWhitepaper(){var postData=$("#newsletterModuleFormWhitepaper").serialize();var requestOptions={url: '/newsletters/pcw_module_processor',data: postData,success: function(data,textStatus){$("#smbWhitepaperAlert").fadeOut("slow",function(){$(this).html(data).fadeIn("slow");})}};$.ajax(requestOptions)} More from the PCWorld BusinessCenter
How to Completely Erase a Hard Drive 
Calling Dick Tracy: Sony's Wristwatch Remote for Android 
10 Products Changing the Business World 
6 Ways to Improve Your W-iFi Network 
Google Chrome: 5 Must-Have Tips and Tricks 
Apple iPad: The Low-Price Leader? 
Nokia Names Microsoft's Elop as New CEO 
Why Intel's Infineon Buy Is a Smart Move 
Deal With It, Boss: Workers Want Android, iPhone Devices 
PCWorld.com is the Web's trusted resource for management-level buyers and users of technology products, reaching an average of more than 11 million unique visitors per month (HitBox, January - June 2009).
More About Us » FAQ »ResourcesTwitterRSSNewslettersContact UsMagazine Customer ServiceAdvertiseNetworkPCWorldPCWorld Business CenterMacworldMacUserMac OS X HintsiPhone Central
NameCityAddress 1StateZipAddress 2E-mail (optional)Canadian Residents | Foreign Residents | Gift SubscriptionsCustomer Service | Privacy Policy© 1998-2009, PCWorld Communications, Inc. Terms of Service Agreement Privacy Policy Community Standards
The Wall Street Journal Business Welcome, Logout My Account My Journal Help Message Center ( new) 
More Industries 
Accounting Advertising Airlines Banking Chemicals Computer Hardware Computer Software Consumer Products Defense & Aerospace Broadcasting & Entertainment Financial Services & Insurance Food & Tobacco Hospitality Industrial Goods & Services Media Agencies Paper & Forest Products Pharmaceutical & Biotech Real Estate Retail Semiconductors Transportation 
Close
Email 
Order Reprints Share: 
![[OB-KJ544_NYOPEN_C_20101007164629.jpg]](/OB-KJ544NYOPENC20101007164629.jpg)
Trash Tours: Off-Limits Waste Facilities Welcome the Curious![[LustigA1]](/P1-AX581ALustiC20101007192907.jpg)
In Hunt for Dubai Hit Men, Trail Cools![[OB-KJ795_1008th_C_20101008115515.jpg]](/OB-KJ7951008thC20101008115515.jpg)
October Mystery: Rays Offense Disappears ![[PRIVACY2_SUB]](/WO-AC886PRIVACC20101007185008.jpg)
Stars Boost Use of U.K. Gag Rules![[OB-KJ670_archer_C_20101008035316.jpg]](/OB-KJ670archerC20101008035316.jpg)
CWG Day 5: India's Medals Tally![[CUBA]](/WK-AV641CUBAC20101007202224.jpg)
In Cuba, an 'Extended Family' Reunites![[wchaple7]](/EW-AJ257wchaplC20101007165918.jpg)
How to Buy Contemporary Art![[100710pod03]](/OB-KJ450100710C20101007145332.jpg)
Photos of the Day: Oct. 7![[Gardener3]](/OB-KI535GardenC20101005122636.jpg)
What Happened to the Mopheads?Videoprevious nextOpinion Journal Opinion Journal: 95,000 Lost Jobs3:21Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: A Nobel for Liu Xiaobo7:18Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Mario Vargas Llosa's Nobel2:54Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: The Progress in Afghanistan6:57Opinion Journal Obama Pulls Down His Party2:21Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: More Job Losses2:21Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Missing Stimulus Money162:00Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Ending the War in Afghanistan?9:20Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Britain's Welfare State Woes5:44Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: The Enthusiasm Gap9:55Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Will Voters Bite Blue Dogs?4:38Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: The Campaign Against Free Trade 9:36Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Running Against ObamaCare3:50Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Creating Another Facebook?9:37Opinion Journal Opinion Journal: Burgers, Fries and ObamaCare5:16 Most Recommended CommentsComments CommentersCommenters 1. “The Democratic party is falling...;” - David Pearlman 106 Recommendations 2. “Christine O'Donnell dated a...;” - James Rodesiler 90 Recommendations 3. “Perhaps most pernicious is the...;” - Steve Fleischer 74 Recommendations 4. “Wall Street is a den of agnostics...;” - David Pearlman 72 Recommendations 5. “Once again, Ms. Noonan is late to...;” - J. Scott Shipman 68 Recommendations 
Peter Venetoklis 1229 Recommendations 
jean balloon 1023 Recommendations 
Matilda Anders 527 Recommendations 
Joseph Wootten 438 Recommendations 
Dave Cavena 402 Recommendations More in BusinessBofA Halts All Foreclosure SalesDoubts Emerge Over BP's StudyGenzyme to Explore AlternativesSchlumberger in Bribery ProbeSanofi-Aventis to Lay Off 1,700 U.S. Employees 
null Email Newsletters and Alerts
Digital NetworkWSJ.comMarketwatch.comBarrons.comSmartMoney.comAllThingsD.comFinance Jobs at FINSBigCharts.comVirtual Stock ExchangeProfessorJournal.comWSJ U.S. EditionWSJ Asia EditionWSJ Europe EditionWSJ India PageForeign language editions:WSJ ChineseWSJ JapaneseWSJ PortugueseWSJ SpanishACAP EnabledCopyright ©2010 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved