JJ News Maker: Big-bucks Whitman versus bike-lane Brown

Big-bucks Whitman versus bike-lane Brown Article:Big-bucks Whitman versus bike-lane Brown:/c/a/2010/10/13/EDML1FRK0L.DTLArticle:Big-bucks Whitman versus bike-lane Brown:/c/a/2010/10/13/EDML1FRK0L.DTL advertisement|your ad here SFGateHome of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

SFGate Web Search by YAHOO! Businesses | Advanced HomeNewsSportsBusinessEntertainmentFoodLivingTravelColumnsBuy & SellJobsHomesCarsClose [X]Quick links to the best of SFGate | Still can't find it? see Site IndexNews »TodayBreaking NewsLive ViewsTrafficWeatherSectionsBay Area & StateBusinessChronicle MagazineCrimeEducationGreenHealth & MedicineHome GuidesNationObituariesOpinionPoliticsScienceStyleTechnologyWeird NewsWorldSports »49ersRaidersGiantsAthleticsWarriorsSharksMoreArticle CollectionsBayListBlogsChronicle WatchCity BrightsColumnistsComicsData CenterEarthquakesLotteryMapsPollsReader ViewsSmall BusinessTopicsVolunteeringFeaturesFood »Bargain BitesRecipesRestaurantsRestaurant ReviewsTop 100 RestaurantsWineTravel »HawaiiMexicoSF GuideWeekend GetawaysWine CountryReno & TahoeLiving »Gay & LesbianGreenHome & GardenMomsOutdoorsPetsSFiSSki & SnowEntertainment »ArtBooksHoroscopeLocal BandsLive MusicLocal EventsMovie ShowtimesMoviesTheater ReviewsThings To DoTV & Radio Classifieds »Advertise With UsCarsCouponsReal EstateBuy & SellJobsMerchandisePersonalsPetsPublic NoticesRentals Bay Area & StateNationWorldPoliticsCrimeTechObituariesEducationGreenScienceHealthWeirdOpinion facebook

Debra J. Saunders Archive | Blog | E-mail | Twitter | RSS

Big-bucks Whitman versus bike-lane Brown Debra J. Saunders

San Francisco Chronicle October 13, 2010 04:00 AM Copyright San Francisco Chronicle. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. Wednesday, October 13, 2010

E-mail

del.icio.us
digg

Digg

Technorati
reddit

Facebook

Slashdot

Fark

Newsvine

Google Bookmarks
twitter

Twitter

Comments

Georgia (default) Verdana Times New Roman Arial

Font | Size:

Debra J. Saunders Big-bucks Whitman versus bike-lane Brown 10.13.10 Saunders: Obama team light on military service 10.12.10 ON THE RACE FOR U.S. SENATE Boxer's fiction vs. Fiorina's facts 10.10.10 Behind the meltdown of the climate-change bill 10.07.10 More Debra J. Saunders »

Californians do not face an easy choice in the race for governor - as was clear in Tuesday night's debate at Dominican University in San Rafael.

Republican Meg Whitman so parses her positions that at times she seems to stand for nothing. She has had to over-compensate for her spotty voting record by throwing more than $140 million into her campaign - while she incongruously argues that she can cut the size of state government.

Her budget plan is a joke that over-promises welfare cuts, advocates big tax cuts despite chronic budget shortfalls and then impossibly offers extra funds for higher education.

Voters don't really know if Whitman has what it takes to cut hard bargains with the Democrats who run the Legislature or big labor, which runs the Democrats.

If she has her eye on the White House, and the economy picks up in 2012, she easily could decide to broker feel-good deals that make everyone happy while kicking the can of fiscal reckoning down the road.

Democrat Jerry Brown is a proud cheapskate who has outsourced his campaign to political consultants working for the state-employee unions that have wielded so much clout that the ranks of state workers swelled by 33,000 since 2004 despite chronic budget shortfalls. Yet he blames Wall Street for Sacramento's cash-flow problems.

Brown's supporters argue that their man Moonbeam is no longer a knee-jerk lefty or never was one - and that the irascible Brown is the more likely candidate to play hardball with big labor.

Brown frequently notes that, as mayor of Oakland, he was pro-development and fought environmental regulations that impeded his goal of increasing downtown residency.

True. But at the same time, an inner Luddite was burning in Dao Mayor's very core. You could see it in his antics to delay the retrofit of the Bay Bridge.

In 1989, the Loma Prieta earthquake exposed the eastern span as unfit to withstand a big earthquake. Yet a decade later, when any thinking politician would be pushing for a start date, Brown was pushing for more delays - for a $50 million bike-lane to Treasure Island, a study to explore adding light-rail to the project and a tony design "that expresses the daring of human ingenuity and symbolizes the splendor of Oakland and the East Bay."

Daring is the word. Ten years later still, the retrofit is incomplete, and Oaklanders driving to San Francisco must brave a vulnerable structure supported by old timber pilings.

I saw that Jerry Brown on Tuesday night when he said that he would oppose suspending AB32, the state greenhouse-gas law about to go into effect. "You create uncertainty," Brown explained. "You create doubt for investors."

I think Whitman had it right when she argued for a suspension of the measure in light of the state's 12.4 percent unemployment rate. Whitman explained, "It's not fair to the employees in manufacturing, trucking, packaging, all the other industries, to drive those jobs out of state." Amen.

Referring to the AB32's mandate for the California Air Resources Board to set a "low carbon-fuel standard," bike-lane Brown declared, "My god, they're going to use less oil in California. You bet. We're going to use more California sun and more California wind, and we'll get it done."

He forgets how Sacramento works. Last week, The Chronicle's Wyatt Buchanan reported on CARB's gross miscalculations - overestimated diesel emissions by 340 percent - that could cost California industry $10 billion to $12 billion.

It's the Bay Bridge all over again. Forget the risks and practical consideration. Everything will turn out OK if you mean well.

The problem with Jerry Brown as governor is: Tough times are the worst time for magical thinking.

E-mail dsaunders@sfchronicle.com.

For more election-related news and information, visit our California Elections 2010 page.This article appeared on page A - 14 of the San Francisco Chronicle

E-mail

del.icio.us
digg

Digg

Technorati
reddit

Facebook

Slashdot

Fark

Newsvine

Google Bookmarks
twitter

Twitter

#sfg_object_view .socialtools .facebookcontainer, #sfg_object_view .socialtools .diggcontainer, #sfg_blog .socialtools .facebookcontainer, #sfg_blog .socialtools .diggcontainer{margin-top:2px;}#sfg_object_view .socialtools img, #sfg_blog .socialtools img {margin-top:2px;} 0

Subscribe to the San Francisco Chronicle and get a gift:Sunday + a $15 gift cardFri-Sun + a $15 gift cardMon-Sun + a $25 gift card

Related Topics: California Air Resources Board,񎧅 Loma Prieta earthquake, Greenhouse gas, Higher education, San Francisco, California, Wall Street, San Francisco ? Oakland Bay Bridge

Photos: Historic home in Berkeley

Willie Brown's fave lunch spots

S.F. fixer-upper transformed

Morford: Sympathy for wretched pol

Local Sports Beard Hall of Fame Galleries 1-3 of 21 previous

All tied up: Best boots for fall

Alaska couple converts pickup into...

'Real Housewives of Beverly Hills' party

'Red' premiere

'Hereafter' premiere

East Bay's 25 best nature walks and...

India in all its beauty

17 best souvenirs to buy in Mexico

Hollywood actors, then and now

Power of Women Luncheon

6 surprising ways to make waves in...

2010 Ryder Cup

At Paris, conventional engines still...

Beach escapes for the summer-deprived

Gail Machlis' shared garden in Berkeley

'Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps...

Black, white and homey all over

Home tours showcase Bay Area living

'Easy A' premiere

French Laundry's garden a 4-star...

The 35th Toronto International Film...

advertisement|your ad here

Nicole Richie takes aim at paparazziThey're all out: 33 miners raised safely in ChileCalif. GOP candidate Whitman visits LA restaurantBrown's comment could help Prop. 8 forcesAutopsy: Ex-Olympian Pettigrew committed suicideWives vs. mistresses: Are miners trapped again?Fairfield mom suspected of killing twin girlsSympathy for the wretched politicianNontoxic bedbug control is possibleProfessional HR services for small businessesThe Chronicle Recommends: German RieslingChristian schools lose appeal bid in UC caseS.F.'s Zero Zero a haven for upscale pizzaBernal Heights fixer-upper hip to be squareWhitman, Brown tangle over maid, slur in debateJudge orders military to stop discharging gaysProp. 19's legal marijuana could improve safetyDying child mocked on Internet: A new low for humanity? : The Mommy FilesYggdrasil wildlife center hopes for rescueThey're all out: 33 miners raised safely in ChileWhitman, Brown clash in final debate tonight